Government Computer News
Senators to FBI: Get a VCF refund
Proposal would pit bureau against SAIC over failure
The Senate’s draft of the appropriations bill for the Justice Department and the FBI would order the bureau to use “all means necessary” to try to recover funds from the vendor of its failed Virtual Case File project.
Digg
De.licio.us
Slashdot
Technorati
In an unusual action, according to several sources, the draft legislation—known as HR 5672, the Departments of Commerce and Justice, Science and Related Agencies appropriations bill—directs the bureau to retrieve as much as $104 million from the defaulted VCF contract.
The FBI hired Science Applications International Corp. of San Diego in 2001 to build VCF, which was intended to create an investigative case management system. The FBI pulled the plug in 2005 after realizing the system would not work.
A key sentence in the Senate report language for HR 5672 reads: “In addition, the Committee expects the FBI to use all means necessary, including legal action, to recover all erroneous charges from the VCF contractor ... .”
The Senate’s reference to “the VCF contractor” especially singles out SAIC.
The FBI and SAIC both declined to comment on the legislation and related VCF matters.
If the FBI could recover funds, the bill would direct the bureau to use the money it would potentially recover from the VCF contractors on its current case management project, known as Sentinel.
The House version of the bill does not include a similar provision—meaning if the full Senate passes the bill with the language intact, it still could be stripped out during the conference committee session between the two bodies.
If the FBI were to try to take legal action to recover the VCF funds, it would be stepping into a legal and political minefield, sources close to the project said.
For one thing, even after the FBI had decided to scuttle the investigative case management system, SAIC recommended that the bureau should deploy VCF and made detailed technical proposals on how it could be salvaged.
Another critical problem is that the bureau has accepted some responsibility for the demise of the VCF project [GCN.com, Quickfind 714]. Sources close to the project said that some of the senior officials in place during the VCF fiasco—including director Robert Mueller—still hold powerful jobs in the bureau, and their reputations could suffer if a public lawsuit or civil trial unveiled the details of their roles.
![1105 Government Information Group [valor]](/images/1105logo_website.gif "Government Computer News [valor]")
© 1996-2008 1105 Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
